An estimated 12,000 - 15,000 union members along with students, environmentalists, animal rights supporters and other activists marched through the streets of Miami Thursday demanding an end to the FTAA and other destructive trade deals.
"This is about jobs. It's about our future," said Tom Edwards, a Minneapolis postal worker. "If we don't stop these trade agreements now we won't have jobs in a few years, and we won't have our democracy either," he added.
The FTAA negotiations in Miami were pushing to dramatically extend the scope of NAFTA to include more countries and more types of trade. Some people have dubbed the FTAA, "NAFTA on steroids," because it impacts not only manufacturing jobs, but services, including public services, health care, construction, educational, and postal services.
As part of a new generation of trade deals that specifically targets the types of laws we can pass, the FTAA will threaten many of our current environmental, worker, human rights and health and safety protections as being illegal barriers to free trade.
Jamison Tessneer, a student at University of Minnesota, agreed. "These trade deals go after our democracy and we have to stop them," he said.
Thursday's protests did not halt the FTAA talks and by the end of Thursday trade ministers had reached an unexpected early agreement. Many of the details of the agreement are still unavailable, but it is clear that the framework agreement fell far short of the ambitious agenda many trade ministers came into the talks to press.
"All that was agreed was to scale back the FTAA scope and punt all of the hard decisions to an undefined future venue so as to not make Miami the Waterloo of the FTAA," Lori Wallach, Director of Public Citizens' Global Trade Watch told the Miami Herald newspaper.
The demonstrations did successfully draw a sharp distinction between the trade talks on the inside of the Intercontinental Hotel and the thousands of police officers outside who cordoned off streets. Many participants commented on the stark contrast between the police lines and security fence and FTAA-proponents' claims that the FTAA will be good for the hemisphere and good for workers.
Tom Edwards saw a glaring contradiction between the police who stood on the outside facing ordinary citizens with plastic shields, heavily armed with long wooden batons, rubber bullets and paint guns, stun grenades, pepper spray and tear gas and the secret trade talks taking place inside.
"I served in the military for many years," Edwards said, "and when I see the police trying to prevent me from speaking I have to ask if this is the country I fought for." He added, "The truth is that when I see what is happening here I am sometimes ashamed."
The heavy police presence may have reduced the number of people who felt safe to attend Thursday's rally/march. By early Thursday morning much of downtown Miami was cordoned off. Police halted public transportation around the security zone and it was extraordinarily difficult to move around. According to the AFL-CIO, 87 buses with union supporters and seniors were tuned away and denied access to the rally/march.
The heightened show of force did not stop a large contingent of Minnesotans from joining in the march, however. About 300 Minnesota union members, environmentalists and students marched behind a massive IBEW banner held by a cross-section of building trade union members. According to Bruce Colburn, Deputy Director of Field Mobilization, Minnesota had the largest organized presence of any state in the Midwest and perhaps the country outside of Florida, in large part due to the work of the Minnesota Fair Trade Coalition.
Many of the Minnesota participants wore Wellstone campaign t-shirts or shirts from recent Camp Wellstone organizer trainings that read "Educate. Agitate. Organize." Senator Paul Wellstone was the only U.S. Senator to march against the 1999 World Trade (WTO) negotiations in Seattle.
When asked about the proliferation of Wellstone shirts, one Cleanwater Action member replied: "Paul marched with us in Seattle. We have to make sure that he marches with us again in Miami." And as the Minnesota group neared the end of the march route they started chanting "Wellstone. Wellstone!" to the claps and cheers of onlookers.
Among the Minnesota group was also a large group of students from the University of Minnesota. The 27 UMD students arrived at 3:30 a.m. Thursday morning having driven the entire way packed in two vans and a car. Yet despite a sometimes grueling 40 hour drive they arrived in high spirits, and after snatching two hours of sleep many joined an early morning march from the Government Center to the security zone.
At the end of the day, having spent less than 24 hours in Miami, the students had witnessed police charging protesters, tear gas, rubber bullets, tanks, water cannons, armored personnel carriers and hundreds of police officers in full body armor. One student got in the way of a rubber bullet as police fired into the crowd and received a quarter sized bruise on his chest.
Despite lack of sleep and sometime frightening situations, the students all agreed that the experience was "awesome" and were glad that they could take part in trying to stop the FTAA.
This message seemed to be lost on some of the mainstream media reporters. As early as Thursday afternoon, some media reporters were distinguishing labor from students saying the former had a message and the later did not. This bothered Josh Wiese, one of the main student organizers of the UMD group.
"For most of the students who came down to Miami it was not just that the FTAA threatens to privatize public education, but that it threatens our democracy and attacks human rights, the environment and our ability to make a decent living," Wiese said.
The solidarity of the students standing with labor may have been missed by the media, but it was not lost on many Minnesota union members. "They are our future," one St. Paul teacher remarked. Others remarked that it was students like those from UMD, Macalaster and other colleges who would become future leaders in the labor movement.
Edwards admired the courage of the young activists who took to the streets in solidarity with other groups. After witnessing the police charge a group of demonstrators he remarked, "They're in the streets doing our work today."
An estimated 12,000 – 15,000 union members along with students, environmentalists, animal rights supporters and other activists marched through the streets of Miami Thursday demanding an end to the FTAA and other destructive trade deals.
“This is about jobs. It’s about our future,” said Tom Edwards, a Minneapolis postal worker. “If we don’t stop these trade agreements now we won’t have jobs in a few years, and we won’t have our democracy either,” he added.
The FTAA negotiations in Miami were pushing to dramatically extend the scope of NAFTA to include more countries and more types of trade. Some people have dubbed the FTAA, “NAFTA on steroids,” because it impacts not only manufacturing jobs, but services, including public services, health care, construction, educational, and postal services.
As part of a new generation of trade deals that specifically targets the types of laws we can pass, the FTAA will threaten many of our current environmental, worker, human rights and health and safety protections as being illegal barriers to free trade.
Jamison Tessneer, a student at University of Minnesota, agreed. “These trade deals go after our democracy and we have to stop them,” he said.
Thursday’s protests did not halt the FTAA talks and by the end of Thursday trade ministers had reached an unexpected early agreement. Many of the details of the agreement are still unavailable, but it is clear that the framework agreement fell far short of the ambitious agenda many trade ministers came into the talks to press.
“All that was agreed was to scale back the FTAA scope and punt all of the hard decisions to an undefined future venue so as to not make Miami the Waterloo of the FTAA,” Lori Wallach, Director of Public Citizens’ Global Trade Watch told the Miami Herald newspaper.
The demonstrations did successfully draw a sharp distinction between the trade talks on the inside of the Intercontinental Hotel and the thousands of police officers outside who cordoned off streets. Many participants commented on the stark contrast between the police lines and security fence and FTAA-proponents’ claims that the FTAA will be good for the hemisphere and good for workers.
Tom Edwards saw a glaring contradiction between the police who stood on the outside facing ordinary citizens with plastic shields, heavily armed with long wooden batons, rubber bullets and paint guns, stun grenades, pepper spray and tear gas and the secret trade talks taking place inside.
“I served in the military for many years,” Edwards said, “and when I see the police trying to prevent me from speaking I have to ask if this is the country I fought for.” He added, “The truth is that when I see what is happening here I am sometimes ashamed.”
The heavy police presence may have reduced the number of people who felt safe to attend Thursday’s rally/march. By early Thursday morning much of downtown Miami was cordoned off. Police halted public transportation around the security zone and it was extraordinarily difficult to move around. According to the AFL-CIO, 87 buses with union supporters and seniors were tuned away and denied access to the rally/march.
The heightened show of force did not stop a large contingent of Minnesotans from joining in the march, however. About 300 Minnesota union members, environmentalists and students marched behind a massive IBEW banner held by a cross-section of building trade union members. According to Bruce Colburn, Deputy Director of Field Mobilization, Minnesota had the largest organized presence of any state in the Midwest and perhaps the country outside of Florida, in large part due to the work of the Minnesota Fair Trade Coalition.
Many of the Minnesota participants wore Wellstone campaign t-shirts or shirts from recent Camp Wellstone organizer trainings that read “Educate. Agitate. Organize.” Senator Paul Wellstone was the only U.S. Senator to march against the 1999 World Trade (WTO) negotiations in Seattle.
When asked about the proliferation of Wellstone shirts, one Cleanwater Action member replied: “Paul marched with us in Seattle. We have to make sure that he marches with us again in Miami.” And as the Minnesota group neared the end of the march route they started chanting “Wellstone. Wellstone!” to the claps and cheers of onlookers.
Among the Minnesota group was also a large group of students from the University of Minnesota. The 27 UMD students arrived at 3:30 a.m. Thursday morning having driven the entire way packed in two vans and a car. Yet despite a sometimes grueling 40 hour drive they arrived in high spirits, and after snatching two hours of sleep many joined an early morning march from the Government Center to the security zone.
At the end of the day, having spent less than 24 hours in Miami, the students had witnessed police charging protesters, tear gas, rubber bullets, tanks, water cannons, armored personnel carriers and hundreds of police officers in full body armor. One student got in the way of a rubber bullet as police fired into the crowd and received a quarter sized bruise on his chest.
Despite lack of sleep and sometime frightening situations, the students all agreed that the experience was “awesome” and were glad that they could take part in trying to stop the FTAA.
This message seemed to be lost on some of the mainstream media reporters. As early as Thursday afternoon, some media reporters were distinguishing labor from students saying the former had a message and the later did not. This bothered Josh Wiese, one of the main student organizers of the UMD group.
“For most of the students who came down to Miami it was not just that the FTAA threatens to privatize public education, but that it threatens our democracy and attacks human rights, the environment and our ability to make a decent living,” Wiese said.
The solidarity of the students standing with labor may have been missed by the media, but it was not lost on many Minnesota union members. “They are our future,” one St. Paul teacher remarked. Others remarked that it was students like those from UMD, Macalaster and other colleges who would become future leaders in the labor movement.
Edwards admired the courage of the young activists who took to the streets in solidarity with other groups. After witnessing the police charge a group of demonstrators he remarked, “They’re in the streets doing our work today.”