Scott County derailment exposes safety issues

Six train cars plummeted from the bridge into the Minnesota River, and two sunk to the bottom and remained submerged in the river.

Proponents of a bill now before the state Legislature say the incident in Scott County underscores the need for improved railroad-track safety across Minnesota.

The Railroad Walkway Safety Act would re-establish the position of state rail safety inspector. It also would improve track and bridge inspections and shore up walkway areas, where train crews work regularly while on the railroad.

Phillip Qualy, Minnesota legislative director for the United Transportation Union, said the proposed legislation would prevent incidents like the one in Scott County last month.

Qualy spoke to both workers on board the train that plunged into the Minnesota. Neither crew member was hurt in the derailment, though Qualy said both were very lucky.

"The crew felt the usual jog to the side with that bridge," Qualy said. "Then they felt a jolt like that of a broken rail. They spiked the air brakes, saw the first car drop, looked out the windows and saw a second car dropping and then watched the bridge collapse under the train."

High water may have destabilized the bridge, but Qualy said several bridges in the area are worn out and unsafe. "Most of us who work the line have predicted bridge failure in this area for years," he added.

A statewide railway safety inspector would be responsible for investigating railway workers\’ concerns, but the job currently falls upon railroad carriers, who may or may not listen.

"It is reported that the railroad company inspected that bridge earlier on the same day of the collapse," Qualy said. "Company track inspectors are under a lot of pressure to keep up with the carrier\’s daily inspection schedules and obviously, hazardous conditions are being overlooked.

"This is an example of what our legislation seeks to address. It is in the state\’s interest to protect railroad workers and public safety."

Most states employ rail safety inspectors, according to the UTU. Wisconsin, which has 3,400 miles of track, employs three; Iowa, with 4,000 miles of track, employs two; and Illinois, with 7,000 miles of track, employs six.

Minnesota has 4,200 miles of track and no state railroad inspector. The state had two safety inspectors until the positions were abolished in 1985. Minnesota now has two federal track inspectors, who also cover Wisconsin.

Beyond inspecting track, a statewide inspector would monitor rail yards and industry tracks, where workers are on and about the cars around the clock. Switching operations have caused an average of 10.4 fatalities per year nationwide since 1992, as well as 14 amputations and 106 severe injuries.

An inspector also would be responsible for keeping clean the areas where railway work gets done – walkways alongside the tracks. When debris or vegetation builds up in the walkways, it can lead to tripping, slipping or falling.

Between 2003 and 2006, the UTU documented 57 "slip-trip-and-fall type injuries" in Minnesota. That prompted the union to push for the Railroad Walkway Safety Act.

"Quite frankly, there are farmers who keep their pig sties cleaner than the railroads are keeping some rail yards in this state," Qualy said. "It is not acceptable industrial conduct and many bad derailments occur at slower speeds due to track defects in the rail yards.

"Unfortunately our experience has been that when our UTU members report the hazards, the carriers just don\’t fix track defects and hazards soon enough. We\’ve tried to work with the carriers, but they are not really serious about safety when it costs their division budget time and money."

The House approved the provisions of the Railroad Walkway Safety Act as part of its larger transportation bill.

In the Senate, the bill has passed the Transportation Budget and Policy Division of the Committee on Finance, but a hearing before the full committee has not yet been scheduled.

Reprinted from The Union Advocate, the official newspaper of the St. Paul Trades and Labor Assembly. Used by permission. E-mail The Advocate at: advocate@stpaulunions.org