Editor's note: The following article is representative of the remarkable career for Eva McDonald Valesh (writing under the name Eva Gay), a muckraking journalist and activist in the Twin Cities in the late 1800s and early 1900s. At a time when women lacked many economic and political rights, she lived and worked with an unusual degree of independence. Her eyewitness accounts of working conditions appeared in The St. Paul Globe, which pledged, "to ferret out every wrong and hardship endured by the thousands of girl wage-workers and right them where possible."
The Toiling Women
Eva Gay's Trip Through Bag and Mattress Factories of Minneapolis
April 1, 1888
The St. Paul Globe
During my visit to the overall factories last week, one of the girls remarked that she had worked in a bag factory where the wages were low and the rules very severe. Hearing several stories about those factories from girls who had formerly worked in them, and being of an investigating turn of mind, I visited two bag factories, and incidentally two where mattresses were made, in order to see for myself how the girls were treated and if the reports of low wages were true.
Morrison, Anderson & Butchart's bag factory, on First street and Third avenue south, was the scene of my first trip.
The work-room is about 30 x 50, rough-finished with brick walls and board partitions. A large printing press, where the sacks are lettered, stands near the door. A few men are employed, but the work, especially sewing and folding, is mostly done by girls. The machines, which are quite large, are run by steam power.
So thick with dust
On first entering, the air seemed so thick with dust and lint from the bags that I could scarcely see. As one of the girls remarked: “You have to get used to the dust.” The floor was in keeping with the other appointments of the show – that is, extremely dirty. A number of girls were sewing burlap sacks for flour at what seemed a lightning rate of speed.
“How many of these sacks do you make in a day?” I asked of a girl who paused to adjust her work.
“Twenty-two hundred a day.”
“Why?”
“Because we have to average 2,200 a day to earn $1 for them.”
I saw that the sacks as received from the cutter's hand had to be sewed along one side and end. The sacks she referred to would hold 140 pounds.
“Are you paid by the piece?”
“Nope, by the day.”
“Of course you can earn more than $1 a day when you get used to the work,” I said.
“No, we don't never earn no more than $1 a day,” said another.
“Why?”
“Because we can't average more than 2,200 a day no matter how long we work, and to do that we have to work every minute as hard as we can run the machine for ten hours a day.”
“We used to get paid a dollar a day if we could sew 1,000 sacks, and that was called a good day's work,” was remarked by another.
“How much pay do you get when you start in?” I asked.
“Oh, you get about $3.50 a week until you can sew fast.”
I strolled along, watching the girls at work, and concluded that I could become an expert in about two weeks, at the most, so asked a girl if she didn't think I could.
“H'm, two weeks,” she said, scornfully. “You couldn't learn that quick, and ‘sposin' you did – if you get more than $3.50 a week when you're here three months you do well.”
I concluded that I wouldn't try to learn.
Wherefore the paint
The windows were on the side of the shop next (to) the street, but the lower half of each was painted. Climbing on a box and peeping out over the paint, I saw that the windows commanded a pleasant view of the shores of the Mississippi, and was puzzled to know wherefore the paint.
Finally, in my innocence, I said to some of the girls:
“Do you have the windows painted so the light won't hurt your eyes?”
A general laugh was the response. I couldn't see where the laugh came in until one said: “Those windows are painted so the girls won't waste any time looking out. When they were painted, we teased the foreman not to have it done, but he told us that Rev. James McGolrick said that ‘Women ought to be kept where men couldn't see them,' and he was afraid the men passing by the windows would look at us unless prevented by the paint.”
I wondered if the reverend gentleman was aware of the comical application of his remarks. Also, as a certain fixed amount of work was exacted before giving a full day's pay, what difference it made to the foreman if a girl occasionally glanced out of the window.
Pretty near freeze
There was a large stove in the shop, but the spring breezes, sweeping in from various directions, made me shiver.
“Isn't it cold here in winter, or do you have more stoves?” I asked.
“Well, I should remark! We pretty near freeze here in winter; our hands and feet get numb with the cold and we can't get warm,” was the prompt reply.
“Why don't you complain about it?”
“Oh, we do, and get told to work and keep ourselves warm,” said a bright girl.
“Just the same, we have to make our average of 2,200 a day whether it's cold or warm, or else we don't get our $6 a week,” said the others.
“Oh! girls, I'm ten minutes late, and I'll be docked an hour if the foreman catches me,” said a girl who rushed in breathless.
“Why,” said I, “are you docked for every minute you are late?”
“Yes, and more than that. If we are five minutes late we're docked a half an hour, and an hour for being ten minutes late.”
“Oh, well,” said another, “that depends on the foreman. If he likes you he won't dock you when you're late or talk in working hours.”
“Are you really forbidden to talk?”
“There used to be a card posted up there on the wall, forbidding talking or eating in working hours. Somebody tore down the card, and the foreman don't make so much fuss about it now, unless he happens to dislike you,” laughingly remarked another.
By this time I was nearly choked and my clothes were covered with dust.
“How do you get this dust off your clothes?” I asked.
“We never wear a decent dress in the shop; it would be spoiled in a day.” I looked around and sure enough the girls had dresses of all sorts of pieces and patches as various in color as Joseph's coat, and dusting caps on their heads.
“We've got a cloakroom over there at the end of the shop, where we keep our clothes that we wear on the street. You can go there and brush off the dust.”
“Yes, we have lots of style this last year,” said others; “we used to change our clothes over behind the engine and hang up our aprons for curtains, but we told the foreman that if he was so ready to protect us from the gaze of outsiders by painting the windows, why, in the name of common decency, didn't he provide us a dressing room? So we got it after awhile.”
Another shop
I brushed off the dust and went over to Bemis Bros. On Third avenue near Third street. They don't seem to care for visitors. “No hands wanted” is a sign near the entrance door. A little farther on, at the foot of the stairs, is the sign, “No admission up stairs, all business transacted at the office.” I hadn't any business to transact, so skipped up stairs and found the factory large, well lighted and heated by steam. It seemed as clean as such a place well could be.
Apparently about seventy-five girls were employed. Some sewing different sorts of sacks; some clipping the sacks apart as they came from the machine; others standing at the folding machines, where the sacks were turned after sewing.
The girls who worked at these folding machines were obliged to stand all day, and it seemed to be wearisome work. The girls were dressed with the same regard to convenience rather than style, which was noted at the other factory. The dust was not bad in this place, except where the burlap sacks were handled. Several girls had severe coughs.
“Does the dust affect your lungs?” I asked.
“Some of the girls can't stand it at all, and have to leave on that account, and some don't notice it,” was the reply.
A girl was sewing on flour sacks, near by. “Are you paid by the day?” I said.
“No, we are paid by the piece.”
“How much can you earn a day?”
“I've been working two years, and earn from $1.25 to $1.40 a day,” she said. Another said: “Only those who come in as new hands are paid by the week. They work clipping sacks and get $4 a week.”
A general inquiry showed that the rate of wages is such in this factory that a girl by steady work can make living wages. Quite a number earn from $7 to $8 a week, and the majority are able to make $6 a week. The girls are much in fear of breaking the various rules about talking, eating, tardiness, etc., as they say the penalty is discharge for slight faults. But many are willing to obey the rules, though irksome, from the sake of a decent place to work in an opportunity to earn a fair living.
Factories where mattresses are made
Happening to be on the east side of the river one day a few weeks ago, I visited two factories where mattresses are made.
At Salisbury, Rolph & Co.'s factory the room where the girls are employed was bright and clean, walls and ceiling being finished with matching boards. It was heated by steam, well lighted and ventilated. Altogether it looked like a decent, comfortable place for the girls to work in. Bed ticks and mattresses are made on steam sewing machines. One of the girls told me that an ordinary worker could earn $1.50 a day, and experts as high as $2.75. “Steam sewing machines have lately been put in here,” she said, “and the price by the piece cut a little, but we work faster now, so that makes it about even.” I heard no complaint of any sort; the employees seemed well satisfied.
Hearing that the Minneapolis Furniture company employed girls to weave wire mattresses, I next went over there.
Stand all day
Industriously avoiding the “No admission” signs, I at last found the shop where the girls worked. This is what happened: The “forelady” came along just as I entered the shop. Supposing that I was looking for work, she said. “We don't want any hands.” I looked around the shop; it was long and narrow, tolerably clean, well heated and lighted. The mattresses are woven on long tables with the necessary machinery at the end.
“How do you pay?” I asked the “forelady.”
“By the piece – 5 cents for each mattress you weave.”
“I never worked in a place like this; is it hard work?”
“Oh, no,” she replied, “you can see the work is light and you can stand all day; that's so much healthier than sitting at your work.”
I said never a word.
“It's a real nice place to work,” she continued; “you only have to work one week without pay, then you have whatever you can earn by the piece.”
“How much could I earn a day if I worked steady?”
“You could easily weave twenty mattresses a day after you worked a while. That would be $6 a week.”
“Do you think a girl could pay her board and other expenses and dress herself respectably on $1 a day?” I queried.
She lifted her eyebrows in astonishment at my doubts, and then said: “I should say so.”
I rather liked that woman, she seemed so anxious to make the work seem pleasant and profitable when a visitor asked questions.
“We don't have any wash basin, but a pail of filthy water that is changed about once a week.”
“Sometimes the machinery won't twist the wire right and we only weave a few a day.”
“We have to go through a workshop, down two flights of stairs to a closet, and that is used by the men in the office as well as by the girls.”
“We don't have any lamps, and in winter we have to quit when it gets dark.”
“They say the ‘forelady' takes the contract for weaving these mattresses from the firm at a good price and then pays us 5 cents apiece for them.”
Just then the whistle blew, and accepting an invitation to dinner from one of the girls, we went home. I will describe the average girl's home or boarding place and what she gets to eat at some future time.
Eva Gay
For more on the life of Eva McDonald Valesh, who wrote under the name Eva Gay, see 'Joan of Arc' for St. Paul's working people.
Editor’s note: The following article is representative of the remarkable career for Eva McDonald Valesh (writing under the name Eva Gay), a muckraking journalist and activist in the Twin Cities in the late 1800s and early 1900s. At a time when women lacked many economic and political rights, she lived and worked with an unusual degree of independence. Her eyewitness accounts of working conditions appeared in The St. Paul Globe, which pledged, “to ferret out every wrong and hardship endured by the thousands of girl wage-workers and right them where possible.”
The Toiling Women
Eva Gay’s Trip Through Bag and Mattress Factories of Minneapolis
April 1, 1888
The St. Paul Globe
During my visit to the overall factories last week, one of the girls remarked that she had worked in a bag factory where the wages were low and the rules very severe. Hearing several stories about those factories from girls who had formerly worked in them, and being of an investigating turn of mind, I visited two bag factories, and incidentally two where mattresses were made, in order to see for myself how the girls were treated and if the reports of low wages were true.
Morrison, Anderson & Butchart’s bag factory, on First street and Third avenue south, was the scene of my first trip.
The work-room is about 30 x 50, rough-finished with brick walls and board partitions. A large printing press, where the sacks are lettered, stands near the door. A few men are employed, but the work, especially sewing and folding, is mostly done by girls. The machines, which are quite large, are run by steam power.
So thick with dust
On first entering, the air seemed so thick with dust and lint from the bags that I could scarcely see. As one of the girls remarked: “You have to get used to the dust.” The floor was in keeping with the other appointments of the show – that is, extremely dirty. A number of girls were sewing burlap sacks for flour at what seemed a lightning rate of speed.
“How many of these sacks do you make in a day?” I asked of a girl who paused to adjust her work.
“Twenty-two hundred a day.”
“Why?”
“Because we have to average 2,200 a day to earn $1 for them.”
I saw that the sacks as received from the cutter’s hand had to be sewed along one side and end. The sacks she referred to would hold 140 pounds.
“Are you paid by the piece?”
“Nope, by the day.”
“Of course you can earn more than $1 a day when you get used to the work,” I said.
“No, we don’t never earn no more than $1 a day,” said another.
“Why?”
“Because we can’t average more than 2,200 a day no matter how long we work, and to do that we have to work every minute as hard as we can run the machine for ten hours a day.”
“We used to get paid a dollar a day if we could sew 1,000 sacks, and that was called a good day’s work,” was remarked by another.
“How much pay do you get when you start in?” I asked.
“Oh, you get about $3.50 a week until you can sew fast.”
I strolled along, watching the girls at work, and concluded that I could become an expert in about two weeks, at the most, so asked a girl if she didn’t think I could.
“H’m, two weeks,” she said, scornfully. “You couldn’t learn that quick, and ‘sposin’ you did – if you get more than $3.50 a week when you’re here three months you do well.”
I concluded that I wouldn’t try to learn.
Wherefore the paint
The windows were on the side of the shop next (to) the street, but the lower half of each was painted. Climbing on a box and peeping out over the paint, I saw that the windows commanded a pleasant view of the shores of the Mississippi, and was puzzled to know wherefore the paint.
Finally, in my innocence, I said to some of the girls:
“Do you have the windows painted so the light won’t hurt your eyes?”
A general laugh was the response. I couldn’t see where the laugh came in until one said: “Those windows are painted so the girls won’t waste any time looking out. When they were painted, we teased the foreman not to have it done, but he told us that Rev. James McGolrick said that ‘Women ought to be kept where men couldn’t see them,’ and he was afraid the men passing by the windows would look at us unless prevented by the paint.”
I wondered if the reverend gentleman was aware of the comical application of his remarks. Also, as a certain fixed amount of work was exacted before giving a full day’s pay, what difference it made to the foreman if a girl occasionally glanced out of the window.
Pretty near freeze
There was a large stove in the shop, but the spring breezes, sweeping in from various directions, made me shiver.
“Isn’t it cold here in winter, or do you have more stoves?” I asked.
“Well, I should remark! We pretty near freeze here in winter; our hands and feet get numb with the cold and we can’t get warm,” was the prompt reply.
“Why don’t you complain about it?”
“Oh, we do, and get told to work and keep ourselves warm,” said a bright girl.
“Just the same, we have to make our average of 2,200 a day whether it’s cold or warm, or else we don’t get our $6 a week,” said the others.
“Oh! girls, I’m ten minutes late, and I’ll be docked an hour if the foreman catches me,” said a girl who rushed in breathless.
“Why,” said I, “are you docked for every minute you are late?”
“Yes, and more than that. If we are five minutes late we’re docked a half an hour, and an hour for being ten minutes late.”
“Oh, well,” said another, “that depends on the foreman. If he likes you he won’t dock you when you’re late or talk in working hours.”
“Are you really forbidden to talk?”
“There used to be a card posted up there on the wall, forbidding talking or eating in working hours. Somebody tore down the card, and the foreman don’t make so much fuss about it now, unless he happens to dislike you,” laughingly remarked another.
By this time I was nearly choked and my clothes were covered with dust.
“How do you get this dust off your clothes?” I asked.
“We never wear a decent dress in the shop; it would be spoiled in a day.” I looked around and sure enough the girls had dresses of all sorts of pieces and patches as various in color as Joseph’s coat, and dusting caps on their heads.
“We’ve got a cloakroom over there at the end of the shop, where we keep our clothes that we wear on the street. You can go there and brush off the dust.”
“Yes, we have lots of style this last year,” said others; “we used to change our clothes over behind the engine and hang up our aprons for curtains, but we told the foreman that if he was so ready to protect us from the gaze of outsiders by painting the windows, why, in the name of common decency, didn’t he provide us a dressing room? So we got it after awhile.”
Another shop
I brushed off the dust and went over to Bemis Bros. On Third avenue near Third street. They don’t seem to care for visitors. “No hands wanted” is a sign near the entrance door. A little farther on, at the foot of the stairs, is the sign, “No admission up stairs, all business transacted at the office.” I hadn’t any business to transact, so skipped up stairs and found the factory large, well lighted and heated by steam. It seemed as clean as such a place well could be.
Apparently about seventy-five girls were employed. Some sewing different sorts of sacks; some clipping the sacks apart as they came from the machine; others standing at the folding machines, where the sacks were turned after sewing.
The girls who worked at these folding machines were obliged to stand all day, and it seemed to be wearisome work. The girls were dressed with the same regard to convenience rather than style, which was noted at the other factory. The dust was not bad in this place, except where the burlap sacks were handled. Several girls had severe coughs.
“Does the dust affect your lungs?” I asked.
“Some of the girls can’t stand it at all, and have to leave on that account, and some don’t notice it,” was the reply.
A girl was sewing on flour sacks, near by. “Are you paid by the day?” I said.
“No, we are paid by the piece.”
“How much can you earn a day?”
“I’ve been working two years, and earn from $1.25 to $1.40 a day,” she said. Another said: “Only those who come in as new hands are paid by the week. They work clipping sacks and get $4 a week.”
A general inquiry showed that the rate of wages is such in this factory that a girl by steady work can make living wages. Quite a number earn from $7 to $8 a week, and the majority are able to make $6 a week. The girls are much in fear of breaking the various rules about talking, eating, tardiness, etc., as they say the penalty is discharge for slight faults. But many are willing to obey the rules, though irksome, from the sake of a decent place to work in an opportunity to earn a fair living.
Factories where mattresses are made
Happening to be on the east side of the river one day a few weeks ago, I visited two factories where mattresses are made.
At Salisbury, Rolph & Co.’s factory the room where the girls are employed was bright and clean, walls and ceiling being finished with matching boards. It was heated by steam, well lighted and ventilated. Altogether it looked like a decent, comfortable place for the girls to work in. Bed ticks and mattresses are made on steam sewing machines. One of the girls told me that an ordinary worker could earn $1.50 a day, and experts as high as $2.75. “Steam sewing machines have lately been put in here,” she said, “and the price by the piece cut a little, but we work faster now, so that makes it about even.” I heard no complaint of any sort; the employees seemed well satisfied.
Hearing that the Minneapolis Furniture company employed girls to weave wire mattresses, I next went over there.
Stand all day
Industriously avoiding the “No admission” signs, I at last found the shop where the girls worked. This is what happened: The “forelady” came along just as I entered the shop. Supposing that I was looking for work, she said. “We don’t want any hands.” I looked around the shop; it was long and narrow, tolerably clean, well heated and lighted. The mattresses are woven on long tables with the necessary machinery at the end.
“How do you pay?” I asked the “forelady.”
“By the piece – 5 cents for each mattress you weave.”
“I never worked in a place like this; is it hard work?”
“Oh, no,” she replied, “you can see the work is light and you can stand all day; that’s so much healthier than sitting at your work.”
I said never a word.
“It’s a real nice place to work,” she continued; “you only have to work one week without pay, then you have whatever you can earn by the piece.”
“How much could I earn a day if I worked steady?”
“You could easily weave twenty mattresses a day after you worked a while. That would be $6 a week.”
“Do you think a girl could pay her board and other expenses and dress herself respectably on $1 a day?” I queried.
She lifted her eyebrows in astonishment at my doubts, and then said: “I should say so.”
I rather liked that woman, she seemed so anxious to make the work seem pleasant and profitable when a visitor asked questions.
“We don’t have any wash basin, but a pail of filthy water that is changed about once a week.”
“Sometimes the machinery won’t twist the wire right and we only weave a few a day.”
“We have to go through a workshop, down two flights of stairs to a closet, and that is used by the men in the office as well as by the girls.”
“We don’t have any lamps, and in winter we have to quit when it gets dark.”
“They say the ‘forelady’ takes the contract for weaving these mattresses from the firm at a good price and then pays us 5 cents apiece for them.”
Just then the whistle blew, and accepting an invitation to dinner from one of the girls, we went home. I will describe the average girl’s home or boarding place and what she gets to eat at some future time.
Eva Gay
For more on the life of Eva McDonald Valesh, who wrote under the name Eva Gay, see ‘Joan of Arc’ for St. Paul’s working people.