On November 12, the University of Minnesota Parliamentary Debate Society (UMPDS) hosted an ?in-house tournament? about the merits of organized labor as being necessary in our modern economy.?The debate was attended by some one hundred U of M students, faculty, and union leaders.?The event was held in Wiley Hall on the West Bank Campus.
Taking the pro-union stance was Professor John Remington from the Industrial Relations Center.?The opposition was led by Professor Ian Maitland from the business school.?Both teachers work at the University of Minnesota.?Remington and Maitland were aided by students who are associated with UMPDS.
Professor Maitland began with a lengthy exposition about union bosses, labor monopolies, union exploitation and violence. Part of his remarks also extolled the virtues of sweatshops in third world nations.According to Maitland, these sweatshops are good for American consumers. Professor Maitland also claimed that the belief that unions better the lot of workers was a "carefully nurtured mythology,"and that the "dynamism of capitalist economies," and not collective bargaining, have improved salaries. Professor Remington led off by saying that having unions leads the way to better pay, benefits and working conditions. Using figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Remington said, "Union members earn 28% more on an annual basis, and nearer to 35% if benefits are included," when compared to non-union. The difference grows to 35% when health and pension benefits are included.?In addition, Remington claimed that worker representation in unionized countries provided a safeguard against corporate crime.
UMPDS speakers Stu Whitson and Jason Schousboe continued the case as set up by their respective leaders.?After a series of impassioned and informative floor speeches, Leila Babaeva, the Speaker of the House, called for a floor vote.?On a razor-thin margin of only two votes, the side speaking in favor of unions won.?Those in attendance, much like the general public, agree that unions are relevant today and have a unique place on our nation?s political and economic landscape.
|
| Debate participants (left to right):Jason Schousboe and Prof. John Remington(opposition), Prof. Ian Maitland and Stu Whitson (government) (not pictured, Leila Babaeva, Speaker of the House) |
On November 12, the University of Minnesota Parliamentary Debate Society (UMPDS) hosted an ?in-house tournament? about the merits of organized labor as being necessary in our modern economy.?The debate was attended by some one hundred U of M students, faculty, and union leaders.?The event was held in Wiley Hall on the West Bank Campus.
Taking the pro-union stance was Professor John Remington from the Industrial Relations Center.?The opposition was led by Professor Ian Maitland from the business school.?Both teachers work at the University of Minnesota.?Remington and Maitland were aided by students who are associated with UMPDS.
Professor Maitland began with a lengthy exposition about union bosses, labor monopolies, union exploitation and violence. Part of his remarks also extolled the virtues of sweatshops in third world nations.According to Maitland, these sweatshops are good for American consumers. Professor Maitland also claimed that the belief that unions better the lot of workers was a “carefully nurtured mythology,”and that the “dynamism of capitalist economies,” and not collective bargaining, have improved salaries. Professor Remington led off by saying that having unions leads the way to better pay, benefits and working conditions. Using figures from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Remington said, “Union members earn 28% more on an annual basis, and nearer to 35% if benefits are included,” when compared to non-union. The difference grows to 35% when health and pension benefits are included.?In addition, Remington claimed that worker representation in unionized countries provided a safeguard against corporate crime.
UMPDS speakers Stu Whitson and Jason Schousboe continued the case as set up by their respective leaders.?After a series of impassioned and informative floor speeches, Leila Babaeva, the Speaker of the House, called for a floor vote.?On a razor-thin margin of only two votes, the side speaking in favor of unions won.?Those in attendance, much like the general public, agree that unions are relevant today and have a unique place on our nation?s political and economic landscape.
| Debate participants (left to right):Jason Schousboe and Prof. John Remington(opposition), Prof. Ian Maitland and Stu Whitson (government) (not pictured, Leila Babaeva, Speaker of the House) |