Opponents of a giant Wal-Mart store were heartened when the company withdrew its proposal at Monday's City Council meeting, but are preparing for a longer battle when the retailer returns with a new plan.
The community campaign against the project is one of several mounted in recent years against the growing number of "big box" stores popping up across the state, particularly in suburban areas.
Wal-Mart needed the Inver Grove Heights City Council to change its comprehensive plan for the area near Highway 52/55 South and Concord Boulevard. When it became clear the change would not be approved, the company withdrew its proposal, but promised to return in October with another one for the same site.
The action followed nearly four hours of testimony from neighborhood residents and others, many of whom opposed the project. Residents of the nearby Arbor Pointe community said they would not have purchased their homes if a huge retail store had been included in the comprehensive plan for the area. They expressed concerns about noise, traffic and safety.
Other speakers at the City Council meeting raised Wal-Mart's poor worker and human rights record. Rob McKenzie, president of United Auto Workers Local 879 and an Inver Grove Heights resident, said the company opposes unions in the United States and imports goods produced under repressive conditions in China and elsewhere.
"They (Wal-Mart) are the market leader in driving down wages and working conditions around the world," he said.
Eric Schubert, leader of a coalition opposing the store, urged the City Council to see the big picture.
"This is about so much more than socks and underwear, pants and shorts," he said. "It's about our community, which is at a crossroads."
The proposal called for a 145,000-square-foot store, with a garden center and gas station, on 29 acres. The comprehensive plan for the area calls for a mixed retail/commercial development, including office space.
A four-fifths vote of the council is required to change a comprehensive plan. Only three council members - Vance Grannis, Bill Klein and Rosemary Piekarski Krech - voiced support. Council member George Tourville and Mayor Joe Atkins said the project was too big.
"We need to start getting some commercial development in this town," said Piekarski Krech.
Tourville said the city should look at alternative developments for the site. "There are other things that will come," he said.
Atkins said the store would generate about $63,000 in property tax income annually for the city, but that revenue would be offset by police, fire protection and street maintenance costs associated with the store.
Wal-Mart attorney David Sellergren said the proposal incorporated landscaping and other considerations to address neighborhood concerns. He said the company would return with a new proposal that would be acceptable to the council and probably not require a change in the comprehensive plan.
Bernie Hesse, an organizer for United Food & Commercial Workers Local 789, said opponents will ask the city to conduct an environmental impact study before taking any further action. He said the city is underestimating the amount of vehicle traffic the store would generate and has not examined possible ecological damage.
"You put in 15 acres of asphalt, water is going to run off," he noted. Hesse also said he was disappointed that council members appeared to focus on a narrow question of land use, rather than the effect of a big box store on the entire community.
"There's going to be a negative drag on property taxes if they lose a number of businesses (because of Wal-Mart)," he said. "Nobody is talking about that."
For more information
Visit the Wal-Mart Watch website, www.ufcw789.org/walmartwatch.htm
Opponents of a giant Wal-Mart store were heartened when the company withdrew its proposal at Monday’s City Council meeting, but are preparing for a longer battle when the retailer returns with a new plan.
The community campaign against the project is one of several mounted in recent years against the growing number of “big box” stores popping up across the state, particularly in suburban areas.
Wal-Mart needed the Inver Grove Heights City Council to change its comprehensive plan for the area near Highway 52/55 South and Concord Boulevard. When it became clear the change would not be approved, the company withdrew its proposal, but promised to return in October with another one for the same site.
The action followed nearly four hours of testimony from neighborhood residents and others, many of whom opposed the project. Residents of the nearby Arbor Pointe community said they would not have purchased their homes if a huge retail store had been included in the comprehensive plan for the area. They expressed concerns about noise, traffic and safety.
Other speakers at the City Council meeting raised Wal-Mart’s poor worker and human rights record. Rob McKenzie, president of United Auto Workers Local 879 and an Inver Grove Heights resident, said the company opposes unions in the United States and imports goods produced under repressive conditions in China and elsewhere.
“They (Wal-Mart) are the market leader in driving down wages and working conditions around the world,” he said.
Eric Schubert, leader of a coalition opposing the store, urged the City Council to see the big picture.
“This is about so much more than socks and underwear, pants and shorts,” he said. “It’s about our community, which is at a crossroads.”
The proposal called for a 145,000-square-foot store, with a garden center and gas station, on 29 acres. The comprehensive plan for the area calls for a mixed retail/commercial development, including office space.
A four-fifths vote of the council is required to change a comprehensive plan. Only three council members – Vance Grannis, Bill Klein and Rosemary Piekarski Krech – voiced support. Council member George Tourville and Mayor Joe Atkins said the project was too big.
“We need to start getting some commercial development in this town,” said Piekarski Krech.
Tourville said the city should look at alternative developments for the site. “There are other things that will come,” he said.
Atkins said the store would generate about $63,000 in property tax income annually for the city, but that revenue would be offset by police, fire protection and street maintenance costs associated with the store.
Wal-Mart attorney David Sellergren said the proposal incorporated landscaping and other considerations to address neighborhood concerns. He said the company would return with a new proposal that would be acceptable to the council and probably not require a change in the comprehensive plan.
Bernie Hesse, an organizer for United Food & Commercial Workers Local 789, said opponents will ask the city to conduct an environmental impact study before taking any further action. He said the city is underestimating the amount of vehicle traffic the store would generate and has not examined possible ecological damage.
“You put in 15 acres of asphalt, water is going to run off,” he noted. Hesse also said he was disappointed that council members appeared to focus on a narrow question of land use, rather than the effect of a big box store on the entire community.
“There’s going to be a negative drag on property taxes if they lose a number of businesses (because of Wal-Mart),” he said. “Nobody is talking about that.”
For more information
Visit the Wal-Mart Watch website, www.ufcw789.org/walmartwatch.htm